Reservation
+1 608-745-6776
Visit Us
2756 New Pinery Rd, Portage, WI 53901, United States
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I am visiting from Austin, Texas, where we know what great Mexican food is! I was absolutely surprised at how delicious the food was. As a person with celiacs, I always worry about eating out. The owner came to my table and made sure that I would be taken care of. This place has a fantastic selection of top-quality Bourbons and Tequila. The staff was pleasant and the delivery was fast. The prices were beyond reasonable (4 people) considering the amount of food. The next time I visit Oxford, I will be sure to come through again ”
“ Alonso and his team provided great food and wonderful service at our wedding. Our guests had such great things to say about the food. Highly recommend La Tolteca for bath catering and dine in! Support your local business! ”
“ What an amazing hidden gem to me. I never knew this place was here till a friend of mine suggested we go there. It was packed. ”
“ This place is Amazing!!! Always Always excellent service and food. Every time we eat here they always make us feel welcome. The service is always excellent the food is always excellent! The individuals that operate this place are doing it Right! This place is a one of the few left that is great in Portage! I hope this place always succeeds and continues to grow the leaps and bounds they deserve! Thank you!!!!! ”
“ We ordered takeout here for the first time this evening and WOW! Everything was absolutely phenomenal beyond any expectations we could have possibly set. Everything is so fresh and the portions are generous! Highly recommend the California burrito, steak tacos, and THE WINGS.... oh my gosh absolutely amazing. It was mutually agreed upon that they were the best wings we have had in a very long time. Staff was friendly as well! We will absolutely be back ! ”
“ My wife and I came for lunch and the food was delivered within minutes. The food was delicious and the servers were excellent. While checking out an older man approached the desk and started to yell for service. The staff handled the situation with grace and explained the short staffing (even though they were VERY fast). We will always be coming back. ”
“ I have eaten at La Tolteca a few times and every time, I have really enjoyed the food and the atmosphere. It is a fun time for both your eyes AND your taste-buds. What really stuck out to me though was the service. In person, I have had nothing but kind and fun servers and then I recently had the pleasure of speaking to Alonzo over the phone on a business matter. He was fantastic- just a super friendly and funny person to talk to. I will be coming here again! ”
“ A hidden gem of the Portage restaurant scene. Atmosphere is fun and hospitable. We were seated immediately the service was outstanding. The menu is simply enormous and almost overwhelming, but in a good way. There were endless options of beef, pork and chicken cuisine. We went with pork carnita style soft shell street type tacos. The meal was served so fast we hardly got to the chips and salsa provided. Impressive! The guacamole was simply delicious and perfect. The portion size was above average for the price. The taste was explosively good and very fresh with large portion sides. You won’t leave this place hungry for sure. The value for the price was very good. Combined with excellent quality and simply astonishing service, you’re in for a good experience here. ”
Menu
Nacho Cheese Burrito
US$5.90G. Veggie Yucatan
US$12.98Burrito Cancun
US$20.06Texas Burrito
US$20.06Burrito Fajita
US$18.29
About
La Tolteca Authentic Mexican Cuisine
Welcome to La Tolteca Authentic Mexican Cuisine, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Portage, Wisconsin. Located at 2756 New Pinery Rd, this charming establishment not only serves up culinary delights but also exemplifies a commitment to excellent service and customer care. With a vibrant atmosphere and a menu that boasts traditional Mexican fare, La Tolteca invites you to indulge in an authentic dining experience that resonates with flavor and warmth.
As I stepped into La Tolteca, I was immediately struck by its welcoming ambiance. The aroma of spices wafted through the air, enticing my taste buds. One of the standout features of this restaurant is its focus on quality ingredients and preparation. Customers rave about the freshness of the dishes, which range from mouthwatering California burritos to delicious steak tacos. I was particularly impressed by the glowing review from hanna wiedmaier, who described the wings as "the best they have had in a very long time." It's a testament to La Tolteca's commitment to serving food that not only satisfies hunger but also elevates the dining experience.
Customer reviews frequently highlight the attentive service at La Tolteca. The owner’s personal touch, ensuring that guests with dietary restrictions are well taken care of, showcases a level of hospitality that is increasingly rare. This thoughtfulness transcends typical dining experiences, as evidenced by the glowing commentary from DustyGirl Kosmach, who appreciated the diligence in accommodating her celiac needs while enjoying a delightful meal. Such consideration makes La Tolteca a go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike.
Moreover, La Tolteca is not just a restaurant; it’s a community favorite for events like weddings! Brooke Atkinson praised the team's ability to provide exceptional catering, confirming that the quality of the food and service leaves a lasting impression. It's clear that whether you're dining in or opting for takeout, the restaurant's mission is to create memorable culinary experiences that keep patrons coming back for more.
In addition to the fantastic food, La Tolteca boasts an extensive selection of premium Bourbons and Tequilas, which perfectly complement their dishes. The reasonable prices offer great value, making it easy for families and groups to enjoy a hearty meal without breaking the bank.
In summary, La Tolteca Authentic Mexican Cuisine shines as a beacon of quality and warmth in Portage. From their dedicated service to their flavorful dishes, it is a place where every bite tells a story of tradition and passion. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by—your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table